| Updates & Special Announcements |
|
|
| Forums > Updates & Special Announcements > Site Idea for judging mode! |
|
|
|
scave
 United States
Designer
Entries :0
Participated : 594
Forum Posts : 30
Joined : Oct 16, 2009
Account: suspended
|
| Posted On: Oct 11, 2010
|
| |
How about making the first place designer during "judging mode" able to upload revised verison's of final design. This way the CH and designer tweak the design fr final last minute changes.
Thanks! |
|
|
hazeljane
 Malaysia
Designer
Entries :8144
Participated : 1133
Forum Posts : 71
Joined : Oct 16, 2009
Account: Active
|
| Posted On: Oct 17, 2010
|
| |
| I totally agree with you :) |
|
|
LogoBot
United States
Designer
Entries :4047
Participated : 323
Forum Posts : 150
Joined : Apr 2, 2010
Account: Active
|
| Posted On: Oct 17, 2010
|
| |
| I agree 100%. |
|
|
LogoBot
United States
Designer
Entries :4047
Participated : 323
Forum Posts : 150
Joined : Apr 2, 2010
Account: Active
|
| Posted On: Oct 19, 2010
|
| |
| Joe, if at all possible, this LMW site feature REALLY needs to be added. I'm dealing with a "judging" client as I write this post who's need to see a few color variations of a #1 ranking. I referred them to you and said they would have to reopen the contest – I've not head back as of yet. If there's any way we can add this feature to LMW I think it would really help us a LOT – it's VERY beneficial to the #1 ranked designer, and a LOT LESS headache and worry for the client. |
|
|
SubAdmin-MP
United States
Designer
Entries :1
Participated : 1
Forum Posts : 269
Joined : Mar 23, 2010
Account: active
|
| Posted On: Oct 25, 2010
|
| |
| We understand the objective. But sometimes CH asks for minor tweaks not just to the 1st placer. Thanks. :) |
|
|
scave
United States
Designer
Entries :0
Participated : 594
Forum Posts : 30
Joined : Oct 16, 2009
Account: suspended
|
| Posted On: Oct 27, 2010
|
| |
| I understand but I am talking about after the CH selects the winner he (or) she should be able to keep uploading tweaked versions if the CH decides to do some revised versions. |
|
|
SubAdmin-MP
United States
Designer
Entries :1
Participated : 1
Forum Posts : 269
Joined : Mar 23, 2010
Account: active
|
| Posted On: Oct 30, 2010
|
scave wrote:
I understand but I am talking about after the CH selects the winner he (or) she should be able to keep uploading tweaked versions if the CH decides to do some revised versions. |
| |
| Your post mentioned about during the 'judging mode' :) You are usually given access to directly submit minor revision to the CH whenever you are selected as the winner. Thanks. |
|
|
tavo
United States
Designer
Entries :4061
Participated : 1174
Forum Posts : 323
Joined : Jul 21, 2009
Account: Active
|
| Posted On: Nov 15, 2010
|
| |
I understand this guys, but my 2 cents is to do what I do with clients... after you select me as your winner I will do any variation you might like, but the concept of the logo is what Im selling you... color scheme and visual composition open to customization!!!
Dont do 20 revisions just to be denied the winning spot after... ;)
your time is the must expensive thing here! |
|
|
heru
 Indonesia
Designer
Entries :4614
Participated : 1559
Forum Posts : 46
Joined : Sep 13, 2009
Account: Active
|
| Posted On: Nov 16, 2010
|
| |
I got 50$ extra for a little revise.
:) |
|
|
cholid
Indonesia
Designer
Entries :5288
Participated : 1123
Forum Posts : 153
Joined : Sep 14, 2009
Account: Active
|
| Posted On: Nov 16, 2010
|
heru wrote:
I got 50$ extra for a little revise.
:) |
| |
| ... ;) Sometimes it happens ... that more value |
|
|
parkje
United States
Designer
Entries :2291
Participated : 557
Forum Posts : 326
Joined : Jan 23, 2010
Account: active
|
| Posted On: Dec 3, 2010
|
tavo wrote:
I understand this guys, but my 2 cents is to do what I do with clients... after you select me as your winner I will do any variation you might like, but the concept of the logo is what Im selling you... color scheme and visual composition open to customization!!!
Dont do 20 revisions just to be denied the winning spot after... ;)
your time is the must expensive thing here! |
| |
Tavo i agree I am going through this on the YardHelpers contest...I have no problem tweaking desings for clients but I am afraid in the end I may take second or third and be S.O.L. But my goal is to make the CH happy...just dont know when to stand my ground.
Sam |
|
|
ta99bobotw
United States
ContestHolder
Forum Posts : 1
Joined : Nov 30, 2010
Account: Active
|
| Posted On: Dec 8, 2010
|
| |
Hi, I'm CH for YardHelpers. Just want to put in perspective of CH on the revisions. When looking for a concept I find it hard to decide quite honestly between some submissions that are quite different which one I might want to go with. It's is very important the impression it makes when people see it on my truck and could determine whether they call me or not.
It's also difficult to decide between submissions that are similar. And to make a final decision it's important to get every one of them revised as close as possible to "perfect" if there is such a thing. I have thought about this as I have been asking for revisions and certainly don't want to waste anyones time but I think it's best to compare everyones "final" version. One designer didn't put any effort into my suggestions and ended up going from an early great start to not even in top 10.
Another issue is that of the top 10 right now there are several that I could see being number one because they are similar in concept but I have tried to be accurate in rankings. Nonetheless when it's all over I may think differently than I do now or get input from someone that changes my mind. Who knows when it is very close?
Don't really have a solution. Maybe there should be some payment for 2nd and 3rd but that's not the way the board is set up.
I assure everyone that I understand the value of time but also want the best logo possible. Other CH's undoubtedly are same. I suppose from designers standpoint another alternative is to only work by the hour for individual clients and I could understand it as I've seen some who entered hundreds of contests and haven't won. That doesn't pay bills.
Anyway good luck to everyone in my contest. |
|
|
parkje
United States
Designer
Entries :2291
Participated : 557
Forum Posts : 326
Joined : Jan 23, 2010
Account: active
|
| Posted On: Dec 8, 2010
|
| |
In response to ta99bobotw:
You have been a great CH this wasnt apersonl attack on you...Some CH never leave any input at all and that doesnt help us help them at all... I think your contest is going very well with some pretty cool designs...I might have been letting my emotions get the best of me and for that I appologize.
Best Wishes on your contest
Sam |
|
|
|
|
| |
